Back to the Liverpool Newsfeed

SIMON JORDAN: The rise of so-called fan commentators like Rio Ferdinand, Gary Neville or Jamie Carragher is not a bad thing. Football is steeped in emotion – why should they be impartial?

We're often told in today's society that feelings can trump facts and thus those very feelings are so very important and defining. Yet now we have commentators invested in the game and showing some degree of emotion, it appears we don't want that either!

I'm referring to the criticism aimed at Rio Ferdinand and Robbie Savage for their very excitable reaction – conveniently captured by a commentators' cam - to Manchester United's comeback win in Europe.

Clive Tyldesley has led the dissenters, comparing the mainstream broadcaster TNT to a Fans TV channel.

I'm not sure I agree with him.