Stunning strikes by Steven Gerrard (2007-08), Fernando Torres (2008-09 and 2009-10), Dirk Kuyt (2010-11) and Luis Suarez (2011-12) qualified through the daily polls for each season.
Now you must choose which of their goals should join Robbie Fowler, John Arne Riise and Gerrard – plus one more to come – in the final vote.
Refresh your memory of the five contenders by watching the video above and then have your say below before the deadline of 10pm BST on Sunday.