We've played this before but you name something that is underrated, overrated and just right. I'll start off with something Chiefs related and then a holiday edition.
Painful Chiefs playoff losses edition
Underrated: 2006. No one seems to talk about this one as a painful playoff loss but Larry Johnson was one of the league's best backs and the Colts had one of the worst run defenses.
Overrated: 2003. That team was so obviously flawed on defense by that point in the season.
Just right: 1997.