The Kansas City Chiefs rookie first-round pick, cornerback Marcus Peters, taking a Peyton Manning pass 55 yards the other way at Arrowhead Stadium in front of Chiefs Kingdom for a pick-six interception return that gave the Chiefs a 14-0 lead midway through the second quarter.

But that moment would eventually dissipate into a cloud of heartache, and not just for the fans who were cheering Peters every step of the way on his return just a few hours prior, but for Peters, who said after the game that he’s not happy with the night even after a good individual performance.