Ask anyone online what the Colts should do in the 1st Round of the 2025 NFL draft, and you will likely get one of two answers:
- The Colts have to draft Tyler Warren, Tight End is a major hole.
- The Colts have to draft Malachi Starks, a top tier Safety is essential for Anarumo’s scheme.
And those answers are not without merit. Warren is the consensus top TE of the 2025 class, has a massive frame for potential blocking upside longterm and a strong Yards After the Catch profile with very reliable hands.