Quick clarification, this rankings will be based on a combination of recent performance, and overall talent.
Quarterback
Deshaun Watson looked rough versus the Chiefs on TNF, but he is undoubtedly the best quarterback in this division. Jags’ QB Gardner Minshew looked amazing versus a renewed Colts defense, but his spot as the second best quarterback is not cemented at all, and the difference between second and last place is very little.
Running Back
Losing Mack for the season hurts the Colts backfield, but rookie Jonathan Taylor showed he can be a top running back in the League, and Nyheim Hines looked really good as the receiving back.