Nevermind that Nyheim Hines scored 7 touchdowns in a single game on more than one occasion in high school.
When he was in college at basically hometown NC State, the school called him The Nightmare on Hillsborough Street in this ad. He said he’d been nicknamed Nightmare since high school, but recalls this time fondly. What can we say? He’s a nightmare with the ball in his hands.
Nyheim also ran track at a high level at high school and while at NC State. The Colts got a two sport Division 1 athlete in Hines, and at 5’9” 196lbs.