Around 8 years ago, I wrote an article about who I believe should be on the Colts’ all time team and I felt it was time for an update. This will only cover the Indianapolis Colts era from 1983 to today. The format will be starter/backup.
Quarterbacks
Starter: Peyton Manning
Backup: Andrew Luck
No brainer on this one; Peyton is the greatest quarterback of all time and Andrew Luck is one of the most talented of all time.
Running Backs
Starter: Edgerrin James
Backup: Marshall Faulk
James gets the nod on this one thanks to his longevity and consistent play with the Colts and while the backup job was a fight between Faulk and Dickerson, Faulk gets the edge due to his receiving prowess.