The Colts' franchise has a history of excellent punters; being last on this list is no insult. There's only been five players in Indianapolis Colts history with at least 20 punts -- Blair Kiel punted 17 times for 37.1-yard average -- so we're only doing a top 5 list:
1. Rohn Stark
Punting has improved over the years so we can't just compare raw stats. Stark averaged 43.6 yards per kick from 1984-94, 5.6% better than the average NFL punter during that stretch and best of the five players on this list.