According to ESPN’s Doug Clawson (subscription), the Indianapolis Colts have had the 4th best quarterback play of the Super Bowl era among NFL franchises:
4. Indianapolis Colts
Best QB: Peyton Manning. Manning received an NFL-record five regular-season MVP awards, including four with the Colts from 2003 to ‘09. During that span, he led Indianapolis to seven straight 12-win seasons, the longest streak in NFL history at the time. He also commanded the most prolific offense in the league during his 13 seasons as their starter.