The Titans, who started the day tied for ninth, had a final round of 298 and a total of 55-over 1,207 (304-310-295-298).
Wittenberg held on to win the title with an 1,180, with Guilford second at 1182 and Texas-Tyler third at 1188.
Titan junior Conner O'Neil tied for 18th place with a 297 (73-77-72-75). Freshman Jonathan Nocek was 64th with a 310 (74-81-71-84). Sophomore Ben Johnson tied for 71st at 314 (80-76-78-80) and freshman Daniel Cole tied for 89th at 319 (90-76-77-76).
Individually, Gibson tied with Garrett Brickley of Wittenberg at 287 and Gibson won a one-hole playoff.