Among the lower tiers of prospects, there are a few general types. There are players with one loud tool, or a particular role in which to excel that forms a narrow pathway to the major leagues. There are young players who may appear raw and undersized, but have plenty of potential projection left to them as they grow, learn, and get stronger. Then there is the all-around player who doesn’t stand out much, but has more polish to his game and few distinct weaknesses. Infielder Andre Lipcius is a good example of that last group.
Upside is certainly important in evaluating prospects, and by and large we’re probably more prone to betting on the players with the loudest tools.