A lot of my reasoning for choosing the players I would vote for is based off the idea of how closely their level of performance was compared to that of an average Hall of Famer at their position and the main basis for that is WAR (though other factors are considered as well).
Right off the bat there were five players who jump off the paper as clear Hall of Famers:
With Bonds and Clemens, I’m simply not of the belief that them taking steroids in the era they did really took away from their overall value.