The Cleveland Indians had a great thing going when Mike Hargrove was the manager. He won two American League pennants during his tenure in Cleveland, including five straight division titles from 1995-1999.
But apparently that was not good enough, as the lack of a World Series title led to him being let go after 1999.
This led to Charlie Manuel being hired and fired, followed by Eric Wedge and Manny Acta. The first two even took the team to the playoffs, but none could discover the success had by Hargrove.