My choice for Cleveland Indians All-Time first baseman was not an easy decision. This spot was the toughest choice on the infield.
There were two clear candidates that rose to the top and both had a strong argument for this position. Ultimately, it was the career impact that drove me to select Jim Thome as my all-time first baseman.
Thome began his career as a Cleveland Indian, drafted in the 13th round of the 1989 June Amateur Draft. He made his MLB debut in 1991 at age 20, and in 1994 won a starting role at third base.