Schumaker's hit cost the Brewers more than the lead. Third baseman Elian Herrera and left fielder Shane Peterson collided hard on the play and both left the game, Peterson under his own power and Herrera on a stretcher. Peterson had just entered the game for an injured Khris Davis.
Joey Votto and Todd Frazier homered for the Reds, who are guaranteed to leave Milwaukee on Sunday night in fourth place in the National League Central. They passed the Brewers in the standings with a victory in Friday's series opener.