If you missed the first Would You Rather article, the game “Would You Rather” gives players two options to choose from. You have to choose one, you can’t change the parameters of the game, and there are no wrong answers (except whatever Brian chooses).
This time around, we’ll be comparing a combination of returners and choosing one. You cannot combine players from the two choices. There are only two choices. You have to pick one. That’s the game. This edition of the game pits some all-time greats against each other, but pairs each great with an all-time meh.