Despite all the arguments, I think the vast majority of Buffalo Rumblings readers are pretty similar in thinking on Taylor. He’s a flawed-but-occasionally-exciting passer that’s not the best in the league but not the worst. We vary a good deal on whether we feel he’s our best chance “in the now,” and a lot of the conversation revolves around one question: “Do his legs make up for his arm?”
First a disclaimer. None of the following information is intended to provide a conclusive answer. I’ll make some methodology notes as I go along, but understand that I know there are numerous variables I didn’t consider (usually with good reason).