Their playoff stats:
CP3: 32.5 minutes/18.8 points/4.5 rebounds/6.0 assists/.460 FG%/.311 3pt%/2.3 TOs
TRo: 36.1 minutes/19.1 points/5.0 rebounds/6.9 assists/.441 FG%/.438 3pt%/0.8 TOs
Now, things get interesting.
It needs to be noted that Terry has played 3.6 more minutes per game than Paul, so he's had more time to accumulate numbers, but the efficiency stats; field goal percentage, three-point percentage, and turnovers, justify his play.
Their numbers throughout these playoffs are nearly identical, but Terry takes the cake in a few spots that I think tell a story.