The debate about Charlie Brewer’s status as Baylor’s quarterback has become less about whether Brewer gives Baylor the best chance to win, and is now philosophical.
Even the most pro-Brewer fans recognize he hasn’t played that well. They might ascribe more blame to the offensive line, or place more emphasis on the uncertainty about Gerry Bohanon or Jacob Zeno, but they know something is off. And even the most ardent “let a different QB play” folks have an abiding respect for what Brewer’s accomplished and feel some discomfort calling for a change.
As we’ve rehashed this argument and gone through multiple discussions, it’s apparent we’re not arguing so much about “Just how gone is Brewer’s arm?