“Fans are divided, bad player.” A hard-fought race here, before almost the last player to be nominated swept up on the inside to take the victory. But let’s review the other candidates who turned Sedona Red.
chwalter got the ball rolling with Mark Grace’s favorite relief pitcher, Mike Fetters. He had a fine MLB career - 16 years, with an ERA+ of 116. But for the D-backs, he was not good, posting a 6.65 ERA (ERA+ 69) and being well below replacement level. But his presence on the mound was always entertaining, his place cemented by Grace’s impression of him when called upon to pitch mop-up during a blowout.