Okay, so I cheated. I picked two seasons for Brandon Webb. But how do I pick between those two seasons when they are so freaking similar to each other? Webby gave up 91 runs in both seasons, with 79 earned runs in 2006 and 81 in 2007. Like, look how close those innings and ERAs are? I’m not going to favor 2006 because of the Cy Young award because he led the MLB in ERA+ for both seasons (and should have beaten Peavy for the Cy Young in 2007, too).
So Brandon Webb is my all-time favorite player.